PDA

View Full Version : which kit??



dbrufus1234
11-05-2007, 03:46 PM
which kit would be better for the swirls in the pic, keep in mind this is my first detail, so i was thinkin of goin with XMT, but im scared it wont get out all the swirls

which kit..
Menzerna Ultimate Detailing Machine Showroom Shine Kit with FREE BONUS! (http://www.autogeek.net/menzerna-ultimate-detailing-machine-kit-1.html)
XMT Porter Cable 7424 Intermediate Swirl Remover Kit with CCS pads!Free Bonus! (http://www.autogeek.net/xmtpocainswr.html)

and the pics r with no wax or anything on the paint

makdaddy626
11-05-2007, 04:03 PM
I think you can get a better deal if you shop around the site a little more - but, first things first, do you want the UDM or the PC? There are some great kits with each that contain only the machine and pads, you can then add the polishes of your choice and still come in with a price under the above choices sometimes.

ScottB
11-05-2007, 04:08 PM
Menzerna kit ...

dbrufus1234
11-05-2007, 04:10 PM
i would rather have the PC, but it really doesnt matter. i kinda wanted to go with the PC and pads, with the super intensive (what the difference in super intensive and Intensive polishes) and nano polish, but that is gonna be pretty expensive, would i get better results with the menzerna products??

makdaddy626
11-05-2007, 04:24 PM
The difference in SIP and IP is that IP is designed for the new "scratch resistant" clearcoats. I've used XMT 3 and 1, as well as Menz Final Polish and Nano and the Menz wins in my opinion.

How about...

Porter Cable 7424 & Foam Pad Kit - Car Buffer (http://www.autogeek.net/hk7424.html)
for 189.99 you get the PC, 2 white pads, 2 gray pads, 1 blue pad, 2 low pro orange pads, the backing plate, a couple of mf towels, and the XMT pad conditioner and cleaner.

Add in
Menzerna Intensive Polish PO 91EFree Bonus! (http://www.autogeek.net/menzerna-intensive-polish.html)
for 26.00

and
Menzerna Final Polish PO 85U Free Bonus! (http://www.autogeek.net/menzerna-final-polish.html)
for 30.00

That puts you 246.00 and you get the same Menz polishes as in the kit, plus a lot more pads, plus the cleaner and conditioner, and you get the PC (if that's what you prefer) and save 14.00... Of course you don't get the spiffy carry bag...

One more thing to consider, I know that the SIP and NANO look expensive, BUT, if you're like many here (myself included) and you're going to end up "just having to try" the SIP and NANO, it's a lot cheaper to buy them now than to spend the 50.00 on polishes that you don't want to finish using up first.

Bonifax
11-05-2007, 05:29 PM
I would recommend Menz over XMT too, but I personally like Megs pads over LC ones.

dbrufus1234
11-05-2007, 05:51 PM
The difference in SIP and IP is that IP is designed for the new "scratch resistant" clearcoats. I've used XMT 3 and 1, as well as Menz Final Polish and Nano and the Menz wins in my opinion.

so does that mean that IP wont work right on my clear coat (05 mustang gt)
also do the low profile orange pads that come as free gifts do as good as the regular orange CCS pads??

dontsleeponit
11-05-2007, 06:29 PM
SUPER intensive polish (SIP) was designed for ceramic or scratch resistant clear coats

both SIP and 106ff were designed for scratch resistant, but work just as well on conventional paint, and all kinds of clear. Most everyone on this forum will tell you that these polishes are top of the line, and that they couldnt live without them:D

Also, the low profile orange pads are great, also actually proffered by some people.

dbrufus1234
11-05-2007, 06:42 PM
i am looking at getting the IP and final polish, will they work as good as the SIP and 106ff??

dontsleeponit
11-05-2007, 06:49 PM
I would look at spending the little extra and get 106ff, as it can probably do a little more correcting then final polish, and will still finish down perfect. You could then get IP or SIP if you needed more correcting power.

Its hard to judge from pictures, but I would bet that 106ff and an orange pad would take care of what you got going on there... but Im new to 106ff as well and Ill let someone with a little more experience say for sure on that one.

If I were you, get just 106ff first, then if you need more power, order the next step in menzerna that you need.

dbrufus1234
11-05-2007, 10:12 PM
well what if were to buy XMT3 and then 106ff, does XMT have more cutting power than 106ff??

dontsleeponit
11-05-2007, 10:18 PM
well what if were to buy XMT3 and then 106ff, does XMT have more cutting power than 106ff??

I have no experience with the XMT polishes, but I would guess you could get more cut with the XMT3, but would probably need to polish again with something lighter, like 106ff or XMT1.

I still think you should just try the 106ff first, then buy a heavier cut polish if you need it. Or if you dont want to mess around, you could get either SIP or XMT3 along with it, just to be sure you can get the job done.