Here's my go at it on two different cars, a very neglected Mercury Grand Marquis and a 3-4 yr old Jetta.
Supplies:
-600 grit sandpaper
-1000 grit sandpaper
-Spray bottle w/ water for wet sanding
-Mother's Powerball (smaller red one, all I had at the time, IMO the Powerball lacks cut and an orange buffing pad would work better)
-Meguiar's Ultimate Compound
-Meguiar's ScratchX
-Rubbing alcohol
-32oz Mineral Spirits
-32oz jar of
Minwax Helmsman Spar Urethane (indoor/outdoor) Clear Gloss
-Blue shop towel
-Terry cloths
The first car I attempted this method on was my GF's mom's '01 Grand Marquis. Easily one of the most neglected cars I can think of.
Before
After 600/1000 wet sanding and polishing (multiple heavy passes w/ compound and one pass w/ ScratchX)
So after I had them all sanded and repolished, they looked good. I then cleaned them off thoroughly with the rubbing alcohol and created my UV Sealer mix.
It's 50/50 mineral spirits and urethane.
You don't need much at all, so just make a little bit for two headlights. You apply it w/ a blue shop towel.
Here's after just applying the coating.
Here's alittle bit later after de-taping.
Here's the following day.
The mixture creates a really nice wet look shine even after it dries and it seems to enhance the appearance of clarity in the lens.
The next experiment was w/ my friend's MKV Jetta.
Before
Since these lights were only really rough on the top where the light meets the hood, I limited my 600grit wet sanding to that area only. I did 1000 and polishing on the whole light.
Here's after sanding and polishing
Here's after applying the sealer mixture.
Here's alittle bit later after detaping.
Here's alittle bit later, out in the sun
And here's the following day
I think the results are great right out of the box. The only question now is longevity and durability, which is really the main thing i'm trying to accomplish by doing this. Both of these cars live outside in the 100+ degree south Texas sun, so they're gonna get pounded. We'll see how they hold up.