Coll 845 vs BlackFWD/PinnLiqSouv/WDGPS??

[MinnBobber]

Hi,
I've been using Collinite 845 and want to try something else.

I'm thinking non-permanent so not OptiCoat etc.

Considering;
1. Blackfire Wet Diamond All Finish Paint Protection
2. Wolfgang Deep Gloss Paint Sealant
3. Pinnacle Liquid Souveran

Which product will come closest to 845 durability BUT give a richer shine?
Thanks, hoping to order today during the sale.

Or is there something else you'd recommend?

[rider9195]

Blackfire Wet Diamond will come the closest in my opinion and experiences. Then the Wolfgang comes in a close second. Both these products are very similar except that the Blackfire has been reformulated with special polymers and last longer, due to the Polycharger in it.

Liquid Souveran I am unsure about.

[mwoolfso]

Which product will come closest to 845 durability BUT give a richer shine?

Collinite 915, seriously.

[wgilles]

Originally Posted by mwoolfso

Collinite 915, seriously.

+1

[luv a shine]

I HAVE ALL THOSE.

845 is still my favorite.
blackfire is a relay slickness maker . East on/off
DGPS is ok also. 50 feet deep
pinnical i have not tryed( dont realy us carruba)

[umi000]

Originally Posted by mwoolfso

Collinite 915, seriously.

Originally Posted by wgilles

+1

Agree - 915 will outlast 845, and look better, too - more depth, with that nice carnauba glow.

[CEE DOG]

Bob, my sincere apologies from not answering sooner!! I did just a minute ago. However... Along with that reading your post here I will say durability being important to you.... Go with Menzerna Power Lock. If looks are your most important item than it's Four Star UPP followed by BFWD... Now I want to back track. Being silver I will recommend Ultimate Paint Guard Plus, 3 coats.

Honestly, you can't go wrong with any of these. They are all far superior to the non user friendly and overrated 845. (apologies 845 lovers) I know my personal opinion is just that and we all have our favorites. If we all liked the same thing we would only have one product on the market.

Out of the three you are looking at in your post there I'll go BFWD.

[Y2KSVT]

Would you guys recommend 915 over 476? 476 nets you more wax per dollar, and they both have raving reviews. The difference I see is that 476 is just a little more difficult to remove, but both have pretty much the same durability and look.

[68bowtie]

I love my bfwd and would say go for that. I had 845 and didn't like it. I also used wolfgang and limed the slickness and look of bfwd better.

[Dr Oldz]

Originally Posted by wgilles

+1

+2

Originally Posted by umi000

Agree - 915 will outlast 845, and look better, too - more depth, with that nice carnauba glow.

Originally Posted by CEE DOG

Honestly, you can't go wrong with any of these. They are all far superior to the non user friendly and overrated 845. (apologies 845 lovers) I know my personal opinion is just that and we all have our favorites. If we all liked the same thing we would only have one product on the market.

.

I have to disagree with you here buddy! You well know I have many many waxes but one thing I can NOT say about 845 is that is not user friendly. Have you tried my JTWO method with 845, Corey? I seriously think 845 is very easy and will outlast 95% of the products on the market when considering traditional waxes/sealants!

Originally Posted by Y2KSVT

Would you guys recommend 915 over 476? 476 nets you more wax per dollar, and they both have raving reviews. The difference I see is that 476 is just a little more difficult to remove, but both have pretty much the same durability and look.

I would choose 915 just about every time over 476. Whites would be the only time I would choose 476 over 915 due to 476's ability to add amazing gloss where 915 adds some great depth while adding gloss.